Whenever The Economist writes about accounting, it is a good read. Here is a recent article.
Reforming finance: Accounting standards
Marks and sparks--Accountants draw up new rules for financial firms. The latest in our series
REWRITING laws in a hurry is never a great idea, but that is exactly what the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB), which sets rules for beancounters outside America, has been forced to do. One of the casualties of the credit crisis has been the idea of fair-value accounting—the practice of valuing financial assets, mainly securities, at market prices or the closest thing there is to them. The idea that accounting caused the crisis is specious, but Europe’s politicians, egged on by banks that took huge write-downs when market prices swooned, have nonetheless lashed out. The message has been pretty clear: make banks’ balance-sheets look better, or else. America’s rulemaker, the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB), has been excoriated by Congress and is back at the drawing-board too.
Unpleasant though the political mood music is, change is needed. The existing standards are a shambles, a patchwork of inherited rules riddled with escape clauses. They mix mark-to-market values with the more traditional practice of carrying assets at their cost and impairing them only when managers and auditors think fit. There are also several different ways of recognising losses. The result is that the balance-sheets of different banks are not always directly comparable.
IASB’s proposed solution, announced on July 14th, is to put all financial assets into two buckets. Loans and securities which share the characteristics of loans—in other words, assets that derive their value only from interest and repayment of principal—will be held at cost, provided banks can show they will hold them for the long term. Everything else, including equities, derivatives and more complicated securities, will be held at fair value. Companies will be allowed to start applying the new rules from the end of this year, and will be obliged to by 2012.
This is far simpler than the existing system. But according to one bank’s finance chief, defining the boundary between the two types of assets is likely to prove tricky. For example, IASB is likely to allow only the very top tranches of asset-backed securities to be classified as loans. That could reduce demand for tranches of nearly equivalent risk, as firms become less keen to hold them. Some insurance companies, meanwhile, are reported to be worried about holding all equities at market prices.
Any boundary will inevitably be somewhat arbitrary, however. The end result does look sensible: simple things will be held in more opaque loan books and fiddly things held at market prices. It is hard to judge whether the overall proportion of assets held at fair value will fall, but it seems highly likely. Anything else would result in an outright punch-up with some European governments.
It is this political tension which is the real problem now for standards-setters. Previous battles over accounting for pensions and share options were won in the face of great hostility. It would be hard to engage in such battles now. The best defence against politicking is to continue to merge international and American accounting into a single rulebook governed by an independent body. This is meant to happen over the next few years anyway, but American rulemakers have been dragging their heels. IASB’s pragmatic proposals may make consensus easier to reach.
Tuesday, July 28, 2009
Tuesday, July 21, 2009
Good Corporate Reporting Practice Examples
PWC provides a catalogue of examples of good practice in corporate reporting. The examples are accompanied by an introduction explaining why this example has been chosen as well as a detailed commentary from PWC's experts based on their corporate reporting framework.
The information is provided free of charge, but requires registration before accessing the full catalogue. Once registered, you can login each time you wish to use the good practice examples.
You can search for examples by industry, company name, country, and category or element of the corporate reporting framework. You can download and print examples in PDF format.
Access to the catalogue of good practices examples can be found in the bottom right hand corner of the page found at this link.
The information is provided free of charge, but requires registration before accessing the full catalogue. Once registered, you can login each time you wish to use the good practice examples.
You can search for examples by industry, company name, country, and category or element of the corporate reporting framework. You can download and print examples in PDF format.
Access to the catalogue of good practices examples can be found in the bottom right hand corner of the page found at this link.
Monday, July 20, 2009
Can We Simplify Financial Reporting?
Last Friday, the Global Accounting Alliance (GAA) and the AICPA held the third of three roundtable discussions about simplifying financial statement disclosures. The roundtables were held in New York, London and Beijing and had the goal of determining whether financial reporting can be made simpler and more useful.
One suggestion was to design financial statements with different levels of disclosure so that users would only get what they want. For example, the first level could be general accounting policies, followed by a level around movement within accounts, then changes in estimates and assumptions and finally forward-looking statements.
If you don’t want the full report you could just have Level 1 with collapsible sections, It was suggested that XBRL can help make that possible.
Quotable quotes:
One suggestion was to design financial statements with different levels of disclosure so that users would only get what they want. For example, the first level could be general accounting policies, followed by a level around movement within accounts, then changes in estimates and assumptions and finally forward-looking statements.
If you don’t want the full report you could just have Level 1 with collapsible sections, It was suggested that XBRL can help make that possible.
Quotable quotes:
- It seems (in the U.S.) we’re constantly making changes. If we could step back and look at issues on a longer-term basis, it would help.
- The profession needs to look not only at the disclosure of information, but how information is presented, because people have their own biases around how to develop financial reports
- Companies will put additional information on their own Web sites, but not in their financial statements because of legal liability concerns. There are different liability concerns for each approach.
- Even when companies include more information, it’s not always useful.
- It’s not just more information, but starting a better communication document. More does not equal better.
- Add a brief summary at the front of the financial statement to provide an overview of the bigger picture. An additional summary must be concise, candid and insightful.
- Can we change the equation from being a compliance vs. communication exercise?
- (Financial reporting) comes with a label. ‘Buyer beware,’...for the SME or small, small companies, it’s not something people will feel uncomfortable with given that they understand what’s in the package.
- Companies should be allowed to focus on what’s best for them but the fundamental building blocks should be the same.
- People confuse uniformity with consistency.
- There may be some incremental differences from day one, but eventually a system will converge.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)