Thursday, February 25, 2010

IFRS Roadmap Stretched

The SEC has lengthened its roadmap for adoption of IFRS by U.S. public companies by at least one year. The Commission unanimously approved on Wednesday a new timeline that suggests that 2015 is the earliest possible date for compulsory adoption of IFRS by U.S. public companies.

The SEC also called for more examination of IFRS and a vote in 2011 as to whether to move ahead with required adoption of IFRS.

The new timeline allows companies additional time beyond the previous 2014 deadline in the original road map, set in 2008.

The original road map also would have allowed certain U.S. companies to early adopt IFRS before 2014. The SEC said it is dropping the early adoption option.

The SEC is not excluding the possibility that companies may be permitted to choose between the use of IFRS or U.S. GAAP.

Up for consideration is whether the transition should be optional or mandatory and whether larger companies might transition forst, followed by mid-cap companies, etc.

Issues the SEC will be addressing:

  • Whether IFRS is sufficiently developed and consistent in application for use as the single set of accounting standards in the U.S. reporting system.
  • Ensuring that accounting standards are set by an independent standard setter and for the benefit of investors.
  • Investor understanding and education regarding IFRS and how it differs from U.S. GAAP.
    Understanding whether U.S. laws or regulations, outside of the securities laws and regulatory reporting, would be affected by a change in accounting standards.
  • Understanding the impact on companies both large and small, including changes to accounting systems, changes to contractual arrangements, corporate governance considerations and litigation contingencies.
    Determining whether the people who prepare and audit financial statements are sufficiently prepared, through education and experience, to convert to IFRS.

SEC Chief Accountant James Kroeker said he could foresee FASB continuing to have a substantive role moving forward on IFRS, even post-transition.

Monday, February 22, 2010

FASB, IASB Fair Value Progress

The Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) and the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) tentatively decided this week on revisions to fair value accounting standards, particularly concerning nonfinancial assets.

Highest and best use of nonfinancial assets

The Boards tentatively decided:

  • That a fair value measurement of a nonfinancial asset considers its highest and best use by market participants
  • To describe the meaning of physically possible, legally permissible, and financially feasible.

Incremental value

The Boards tentatively decided:

  • Not to require entities to separate the fair value of an asset group into two components when an entity uses an asset in a way that differs from its highest and best use
  • To require entities to disclose information about when they use an asset in a way that differs from its highest and best use (and that asset is recognized at fair value based on its highest and best use).

Valuation premise for nonfinancial assets

The Boards tentatively decided:

  • That the objective of a fair value measurement of an individual asset is to determine the price for a sale of that asset alone, not for a sale of that asset as part of a group of assets or business. However, when the highest and best use of an asset is to be used as part of a group of assets, the fair value measurement of that asset presumes that the sale is to a market participant that has, or can obtain, the “complementary assets” and “complementary liabilities.” Complementary liabilities include working capital but do not include financing liabilities.
  • To describe the objective of the valuation premise without using the terms in-use and in-exchange because those terms are often misunderstood.

Measuring the fair value of financial instruments

The Boards tentatively decided:

  • That the concepts of highest and best use and of valuation premise are relevant only for nonfinancial assets and are not relevant for financial assets or for liabilities
  • To describe valuation adjustments that entities might need to make when using a valuation technique because market participants would make those adjustments when pricing a financial asset or financial liability under the market conditions at the measurement date. These valuation adjustments were described in the IASB’s Expert Advisory Panel report, Measuring and Disclosing the Fair Value of Financial Instruments in Markets That Are No Longer Active.

The Boards will discuss at a future meeting whether the fair value of financial instruments within a portfolio should consider offsetting risk positions, including credit risk and market risk.

Premiums and discounts in a fair value measurement

The Boards tentatively decided:

  • To clarify what a blockage factor is and to describe how it is different from other types of adjustments, such as a lack of marketability discount, for an individual instrument
  • To prohibit the application of a blockage factor at any level of the fair value hierarchy
  • To specify that a fair value measurement in Levels 2 and 3 of the fair value hierarchy considers other premiums and discounts that market participants would consider in pricing an asset or liability at the unit of account specified in the relevant standard (except for a blockage factor).

SEC Refocuses on IFRS Roadmap

The SEC received over 200 comment letters on the IFRS Roadmap. The letters came from companies, Big 4 Accounting firms, investor groups, and others. James Kroeker, Chief Accountant at the SEC has stated that he is hopeful that the SEC will announce some kind of public follow up in early 2010.

Kroeker had hinted last year that the announcement would be made last fall, but the SEC made no announcement.

In an interview with WebCPA, Kroeker said that politics was no the issue. Rather the SEC’s “diligent and deliberate” efforts, ihave not allowed a quick response in combination with the SEC’s preoccupation with the U.S. financial crisis, plus “re-energizing the agency as a whole.”

Kroeker feels that there is a good relationship between the FASB and the IASB and that they each “hear the thinking of their counterparts.”

“I’m hopeful that it will be much more likely that they’ll come to a consensus on a common high-quality solution. That isn’t necessarily going to be the case on all issues, but I think it certainly increases the prospects.”

On the speed at which new standards are being completed, Kroeker takes comfort in the fact that the FASB and the IASB have completed a “detailed listing, project-by-project, of what they expect to work on, when they expect to work on it, and what they think the deliverables are. If you look at that, there is an awful lot of deliverables that they’re expecting over the next six to nine months. That’s where we’ll see the real results as to whether or not they are achieving the milestones they are setting out for themselves. The other thing that’s encouraging to me is they have also committed to keep that updated, so if there is, in fact, slippage against the milestones, they’re going to update folks as to where they think they are and why.”

Kroeker is cautiously optimistic that the two Boards will complete their planned milestone of agreeing on a common set of international standards by mid-2011.

Kroeker set a precautionary tone on the pace a twhich change can occur: “I’ve already started to hear in the system some commenters saying you may be able to get this done, but it is a lot of change for the system to absorb.

Kroeker contrasted potential approaches, speculating that the FASB and the IASB muct choose between a “implementation immediately, but do they then call for effectively a “big bang” to implement all of them at one point in time? Or do they say, ‘Hey, there’s actually some phase-in?”