Friday, February 5, 2010
Accounting World Does not Need Convergece with U.S.: Major UK Regulator
Adair Turner, chairman of the Financial Services Authority, Regulator of all providers of financial services in the UK, said that the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) risks adding complexity to its fair value accounting rule, if it continues converging with US standards.
“It is not so much that they are in danger of compromising (international standards), it is that, in the process of trying to reconcile them, they make it more complex,” he said.
He went on to say the world didn’t need the US to adopt international standards.
“We have had a capitalist system without full convergence in the past, it can be a complete pain in the neck… it hasn’t stopped the system working,” he said.
Turner’s comments add to growing concern surrounding the convergence project. In July the Fédération des Experts Comptables Européens said there were “diminishing returns”, from further convergence. Two months later Nigel Sleigh-Johnson, head of financial reporting at the ICAEW, said the process needed to be kept under “close review”. More recently, Stephen Haddrill, chief executive at the Financial Reporting Council, said the process should not be about “translating American standards into an international shape”.
Lord Turner’s concerns centre on the boards’ divergent approaches to fair value. The rule forces companies to value assets at market price and was blamed for exaggerating the effects of the downturn.
In the months following the downturn, both boards, under pressure from world governments, sought to revise their fair value standards. FASB’s approach would result in all assets valued at fair value. The IASB exempted banks’ loan books.
The issue has proved a sticking point in negotiations.
Within the IASB there is little appetite for steering away from convergence. US adoption is a key reason driving other nations to adopt international standards. Walking away from convergence might also embolden Europe, especially German and France, which have attracted criticism for politicizing accounting standards. Haddrill said the IASB was “walking a tightrope” but had made progress addressing international concerns. “Because of the politicization of differences in view in the continent, people are failing to see just how far the IASB has moved towards recognizing some of the concerns that Europe has had, whilst at the same time preserving the principles of fair value.”
“The IASB is again facing that inherit trade off between what are the divergent, and in a sense, incompatible demands.”
Thursday, February 4, 2010
Do You Understand Chinese Accounting?
Sir David Tweedie had some interesting remarks after urging the FASB to converge to IFRS.
"Do you understand Chinese accounting? Do you understand Indian accounting? The answer is no. But you will when they use IFRS, and you will invest when you know where the answers are," Tweedie added.
In the United States, the IASB has held talks with the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) for years to bring international accounting rules close together.
"Ultimately, we have to speak for the international community. If we disagree with FASB, we have to do what we think is right," Tweedie said. "We can't converge at all costs. At present, they wish a much (less rigid concept of) fair value than we believe the rest of the world would accept or even think is appropriate."
At the same time, he said he expects the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission will produce a statement in the next few weeks saying what the United States will do about moving toward international accounting standards. "I think they will confirm they will make a decision next year."
"We have all the major economies signing up for IFRS except the United States... I think if they decide they don't want to use the standards, there will be a resistance in the world. I don't think the United States wants to be isolated," he said.
Friday, January 22, 2010
FASB, IASB Agree on Something!
The Financial Accounting Standards Board and the International Accounting Standards Board finally agreed on something after a number of public differences of opinion over the last year. They have agreed to define fair value as an exit price, as a result of a recent joint meeting.
Both the FASB and the IASB have been controversial recently as they have come under pressure to revise fair value and “mark to market” standards to give financial institutions more flexibility in valuing assets that became difficult to trade during the crisis.
The two boards have decided to meet on a monthly basis, to resolve outstanding issues in areas such as fair value, revenue recognition, leases and consolidation.
The agreed-upon definition provides that when markets become less active, the two boards tentatively decided that an entity should consider observable transaction prices unless there is evidence that the transaction is not orderly. If an entity does not have enough information to determine whether the transaction is orderly, it should perform further analysis to measure the fair value.
The boards also decided (tentatively):
- that a transaction price might not represent the fair value of an asset or liability at initial recognition if, for example, the transaction is between related parties, the transaction takes place under duress or the seller is forced to accept the price in the transaction, the unit of account represented by the transaction is different from the unit of account for the asset or liability measured at fair value, or the market in which the transaction takes place is different from the market in which the entity would sell the asset or transfer the liability.
- to confirm that a fair value measurement is market based and reflects the assumptions that market participants would use in pricing the asset or liability. Market participants should be assumed to have a reasonable understanding about the asset or liability and the transaction based on all the available information, including information that might be obtained through due diligence efforts that are usual and customary. A price in a related-party transaction may be used as an input to a fair value measurement if the transaction was entered into at market terms.