Wednesday, June 24, 2009

IFRS vs. U.S. GAAP

The firm Audit Integrity has reported that a recent report shows that IFRS has no noticeable advantage over U.S. GAAP. Also, U.S. GAAP filers have more metrics and greater depth of reporting, and U.S. corporations file more frequently and in a more timely manner than do European corporations. In addition, the report noted that some governance data such as executive compensation and board composition, are reported in much less detail in Europe than in the U.S.

One of their questions:
Does IFRS provide better financial reporting and financial statement data than U.S. GAAP?

The Report’s answer:

A. Depth of Metric Coverage – Overall, U.S. corporations report more detailed financial data. Governance data such as executive compensation and Board composition are reported at a much lower level in Europe.

Several individual metrics were reported on with differing frequencies. In general, U.S. companies reported on more metrics, but certain metrics (e.g., Pension metrics) were reported with greater frequency in Europe.

B. Differences Continue post IFRS – In looking at average metric values, a small number of metrics had notable differences. Along with expectations for differences in financial reporting between IFRS and GAAP, this would lead to concerns in comparing financial statements using different standards.

The study of accounting-related fraud in Western Europe has found substantial differences in the approach taken to IFRS by different countries and companies.

Audit Integrity has been assessing and rating European companies and rating them based upon their perceived level of accounting and governance risk.

Audit Integrity reports that that the riskiest countries in Western Europe, from an accounting and governance standpoint are Greece and the Netherlands. Luxembourg, Austria and Switzerland have the best ratings. Large cap European banks were criticized for aggressive accounting and bad governance.

The study uses phrases like “lack of transparency” and “corporations...hiding losses.”

Audit Integrity also compared IFRS with U.S. GAAP. They wanted to know if IFRS is an acceptable alternative to U.S. GAAP.

The study found that IFRS has significantly improved the consistency of financial reporting in Europe. But they found discrepancies in applying IFRS in various countries. Such discrepancies were not limited to the European Commission’s “carve out” exceptions to IFRS. The exceptions relate to IFRS adoption rates, financial reporting frequency and timeliness of filings. Timeliness of financial statement filing varied widely by country and was significantly slower in Europe than in the U.S.”

Read the full report
here.

Monday, June 22, 2009

Flaws in FASB’s Proposed Fair Value Proposal

The Association of Financial Professionals (AFP) Government Investor Relations Task Force has sent a comment letter to the FASB on the proposed FASB Staff Position titled “Measuring Liabilities under FASB Statement No. 157” (FSP FAS 157-f).

While AFP supports the FASB in its efforts to issue timely guidance on fair value measurement, AFP’s view is that the FASB’s model for measuring liabilities in this FSP is significantly flawed because:

  1. The inability to actually realize the fair value at the reporting date should be considered;
  2. The fair value calculation of a liability should not exceed the contractual value of the debt a company actually owes;
  3. Gains arising from a company’s own credit impairments should not be allowed; and
  4. Any restrictions on a debt should be taken into consideration in subsequent measurement.

AFP says that the FSP assumes that the company has the ability to take advantage of market pricing (e.g., as a result of changes in interest rates) and repurchase its own debt in the open market, which in most cases it does not. The market performance of a company’s debt trading as an asset is not directly correlated to the economic value of the liability associated with its issued debt. A company is only liable for the stated value of the debt upon maturity or early retirement – nothing more or less. Thus, why would a company hypothetically report a fair value measurement above or below the face amount of the debt if the company does not have the ability to actually realize that pricing at the reporting date?

Read the full comment letter here.

Thursday, June 18, 2009

Push Down Accounting

Push down accounting is a method of accounting in which the financial statements of a subsidiary are presented to reflect the costs incurred by the parent company in buying the subsidiary instead of the subsidiary's historical costs. The purchase costs of the parent company are shown in the subsidiary's statements.

Push-down accounting works like this:
Company A buys Company B and borrows to make the acquisition.

Company A pays more than Company B’s book value for the following:

$1,000 Property, plant and equipment and definite lived intangibles
$ 500 Goodwill

Instead of making the entry for the fair market value increments (i.e. excluding book value) to Company A’s books for the purchase, which (simplified) would be--

Dr PP&E $1,000
Dr Goodwill $ 500
Cr Debt $1,500

--Company A makes the above entry in Company B’s legal entity books, instead of its own books.

The entry being made in Company B’s books makes no difference to the consolidated financial statements.

The entry above is generally attributable to the subsidiary, Company B, but was originally, and still likely legally, the parent's entry. U.S. GAAP requires push down accounting.

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has issued a bulletin stating that debt should be pushed down if "(1) Company B is to assume the debt of Company A either presently or in a planned transaction in the future; (2) the proceeds of a debt or equity offering of Company B will be used to retire all or a part of Company A's debt; or (3) Company B guarantees or pledges its assets as collateral for Company A's debt." "Push Down" Basis of Accounting for Parent Company Debt Related to Subsidiary Acquisition, SEC Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 73 (Dec. 30, 1987).

In situations where a corporation has incurred debt in connection with its acquisition of stock of another corporation and these criteria are not met or where the SEC rules are not applicable to the transaction, push down of debt, while not required, is still an acceptable accounting method.

Some corporations have, as an accounting practice, simply placed Company A's interest expense on B’s books. This is generally not acceptable for tax purposes, although could be acceptable in some circumstances. The rules and related jurisprudence are complex.

One common reason for push down accounting is more for management accounting purposes, since Company B would take deductions from income for depreciation, amortization on the fair market value increments and for interest expense.

Push down accounting may not be acceptable under IFRS on transition. So if a company has pushed down fair market value increments into subsidiaries, because the IFRS 1 business combination exemption is available only for business combinations in which the reporting entity is the acquirer, if the reporting entity is itself a subsidiary and its balance sheet reflects the effects of push down accounting from prior acquisitions, those amounts may have to be reversed upon adoption of IFRS. However, a previous revaluation done for purposes of push down accounting can be used as deemed cost in the case of property, plant and equipment, investment property, and certain intangible assets.

More on this topic later.