Thursday, June 18, 2009

New Lease Rules May Ground Some Airlines

According to an article in Accountancy Age, new lease accounting standards could result in a world of hurt for the balance sheets of airlines.

Old lease accounting rules allowed companies to keep lease liabilities off their balance sheets, with the only impact of the leases being on companies’ income statements. New rules are intended to bring leases on to balance sheets. The airline industry are major lessees of aircraft to the tune of billions of potential liabilities.

Southwest Airlines, for example at December 31, 2008 operated 92 leased aircraft, of which 82 were operating leases, or approximately 15 percent of their fleet. Those operating leases are likely to end up being affected by the new rules, adding additional assets and liabilities to balance sheets. Southwest’s leased aircraft are generally older models. Delta Airlines has about 25 percent of its fleet under operating leases, with total payments of over $12 billion remaining on the leases.

Debt rating agencies, institutional investors and some analysts already adjust operating leases on to balance sheets of the companies that they are valuing. However those adjustments don’t show up on published financial statements. The new liabilities may come as a shock to some investors. Some companies may appear to have weak balance sheets.

The lease industry offers companies the choice of operating or capital lease treatment with the terms and payments on the leases often being only minimally different under the two alternatives.

Accountancy Age reports that in May, the Finance & Leasing Association met with other groups in London to discuss the issue, criticizing the new proposal as ‘an excessively burdensome approach for accounting for leases’.

The leasing industry has expressed its views to the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) and the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB). They are concerned that the proposed new standards represent an excessive burdensome on companies and that the new rules may prevent companies from financing assets.

At a recent conference, a representative of the leasing industry said that the proposed changes could have wide-reaching consequences for companies, affecting balance sheets and income statements, but even more of a concern is complexity of the new accounting rules, with small and medium-sized businesses being particularly hard hit.

The IASB is seeking feedback on the proposals with the deadline for comments being July 17 . A final standard is expected by 2011.

Monday, June 8, 2009

Politics and Accounting

This article, from an anti globalization rabble-rouser, does contain some interesting stuff.

The Obama administration’s good offices have encouraged the big banks to launch a multi-front offensive to block any measures that would limit their profit-making, and to weaken already existing regulations.

Last February, for example, financial firms and banking organizations launched a multi-million-dollar lobbying drive to change mark-to-market accounting rules that forced banks to report losses or write-downs totaling $175 billion in 2008. Mark-to-market essentially requires banks to value their assets according to prevailing market prices. The banks have balked at this standard, demanding instead the right to assign their own values to their bad debts, using "internal models."

With the aid of $286,000 in campaign donations to the 33 members of a key House subcommittee, the Fair Value Coalition, the lobby group set up by the banks, succeeded in getting the industry rule-making body, the Financial Accounting Standards Board, or FASB, to give the banks immense latitude in suspending mark-to-market rules.

The Wall Street Journal on June 3 published an investigative report detailing the banks’ use of campaign fund monies to get their way. The Journal reported that the banking coalition spent a total of $27.6 million in the first quarter of 2009 on its lobbying effort.

It focused its drive on a House Financial Services subcommittee chaired by Rep. Paul Kanjorski, a Pennsylvania Democrat. Kanjorski received $18,500 from Fair Value Coalition members in the first quarter. Over the past two years, Kanjorski has received $704,000 in contributions from banking and insurance companies, the third-highest among members of Congress.

Barney Frank of Massachusetts, the Democratic chairman of the Financial Services Committee, received $8,500 from the coalition.

Kanjorski and other recipients of the bankers’ largess from both parties grilled the head of FASB, Robert Herz, at a committee hearing on March 12, demanding that he expedite a review of mark-to-market rules and threatening him with a bill to broaden government oversight of his board if he failed to comply.

Herz got the message, and on April 12, in advance of the stress test results and early enough to enable the banks to pad their first-quarter financial reports, FASB announced the changes demanded by the lawmakers.

According to the Journal, the American Bankers Association was the biggest contributor to the campaign funds of committee members in the weeks before the March 12 hearing. The newspaper quotes ABA President Edward Yingling as boasting, "We worked that hearing. We told people that the hearing should be used to talk about the big problems with ‘mark to market,’ and you had 20 straight members of Congress, one after another, turn to FASB and say, ‘Fix it.’"

The Journal notes: "The change helped turn around investor sentiment on banks.... Wells Fargo & Co. said the change increased its capital by $4.4 billion in the first quarter. Citigroup Inc. said the change added $413 million to first-quarter earnings." The newspaper cites a tax and accounting analyst, who estimates that the accounting changes will increase bank earnings in the second quarter by an average of 7 percent.

The Journal quotes Lynn Turner, the former chief accountant of the Securities and Exchange Commission and a former FASB member, as saying "he doesn’t think the banking industry will be satisfied until mark to market accounting is dismantled completely. ‘Despite efforts by FASB to give ground to the banks, enough is never enough, he says."

Friday, June 5, 2009

IFRS News Roundup

This summary of IFRS news comes from the AICPA. You can subscribe to their daily news feed on their site.


FASB chairman unhappy with direction in rule-reform efforts Financial Accounting Standards Board Chairman Bob Herz said last month that reform efforts for accounting rules are being done in a piecemeal fashion to appease politicians. The end result, Herz said, will be rules that are hastily implemented but not necessarily the best fix for the system. "We desire to get to a common good answer with the IASB and we will make best efforts to do so, but some of the directions we are currently headed in are not to the liking of our board," he said. Reuters

FCAG members see threats to international accounting standards External pressures on the FASB and IASB could result in "tragedy," according to at least three members of a joint board the two groups formed last year. The members of the Financial Crisis Advisory Group said such pressures could threaten "the very existence of international accounting standards." FCAG Co-Chairman Harvey Goldschmid and FCAG members Nelson Carvalho and Michel Prada raised their concerns at a meeting last month. AccountingWEB (5/24) , WebCPA (5/26)

Official: U.S. takes risk by not adopting IFRS The U.S. will be "the outlier" unless it adopts International Financial Reporting Standards within five years, according to International Accounting Standards Board member John Smith. "Those countries already adopting and committing themselves to IFRS will not accept a situation where the United States remains outside the system indefinitely, yet has a seat at the table," he said. For IFRS daily updates, training and other resources, visit www.ifrs.com. CFO.com

Gerhard Mueller: Accounting education must support IFRS IFRS and U.S. GAAP will converge over the next five to 10 years with a few minimal differences to accommodate "U.S. domestic quirks," said Gerhard G. Mueller, a longtime proponent of international accounting. One of the greatest challenges confronting convergence is accounting education in the U.S. fully integrating IFRS into textbooks and the curricula, he said. JournalofAccountancy.com (5/8)

Fund managers pressure IASB on accounting rules update Investors and fund managers want the International Accounting Standards Board to speed up its reform efforts aimed at eliminating fundamental problems with International Financial Reporting Standards. Many blame the rules for helping fuel problems in the banking sector. "It is time to wrap a cold towel around our heads. The end result has got to be an accounting system that looks after everyone and does not flatter profit and to take provisions when they are first apparent," said Andy Brough at Schroders. Telegraph (London) (5/17)

Mixed reviews greet revenue-recognition proposal More than half of the senior finance executives responding to a survey indicated they support a proposal of contract-based standards for revenue recognition, but some questioned how the rules would work in practice. The Financial Accounting Standards Board and the International Accounting Standards Board proposed a revenue-recognition model for use in Generally Accepted Accounting Principles and International Financial Reporting Standards. FASB will accept comment letters until June 19. WebCPA (5/28)

Analysis: New IASB standards on fair value offer consistency AccountingWEB (5/29)

IASB responds to financial crisis with fair-value proposal The International Accounting Standards Board is attempting to alleviate political pressure by proposing guidelines for fair-value accounting standards. "This exposure draft is an important milestone in our response to the global financial crisis," said IASB Chairman Sir David Tweedie. "It proposes clear and consistent guidance for the measurement of fair value and also addresses valuation issues arising in markets that have become inactive." WebCPA (5/29)

CPAs add IFRS knowledge but want SEC to allow more time for adoption CPAs gained familiarity with International Financial Reporting Standards over the past several months, according to an AICPA survey. When asked whether they think the Securities and Exchange Commission's proposed timeline should be changed, 47% said it should be delayed. Twenty-two percent supported the proposed timeline, and 6% want it to be accelerated. The remainder were unsure. Read the AICPA news release. JournalofAccountancy.com (5/14)

"All market participants" need IFRS training The first and most obvious question to ask about IFRS training is just who needs it. According to Remi Forgeas, CPA, the answer is "all market participants." That doesn't just mean CPAs, chief financial officers, accounting departments and auditors, he argues, noting that IFRS training is essential for a broad spectrum of people who will need to interact with IFRS as a part of their responsibilities. CPA Insider (5/26)

EU might ignore IASB, enact its own IFRS, council warns The Financial Reporting Council said in its annual report that the International Financial Reporting Standards, as written by the International Accounting Standards Board, are at risk from interference by European Union politicians. "We continue to have significant concerns that the EU might adopt its own version of IFRS, rather than the standards as published by the IASB," the council said. Accountancy Age (London) (5/27)